Skip to content

Where We Disagree- the divergent opinions between gun owners and non-gun owners

July 17, 2017

Legal gun ownership is heavily regulated in the United States.  Protecting our rights is not necessary when we agree.  It becomes essential to protect a minority view, and gun owners are a minority here in the US.  Pew research conducted a series of interviews last month.  They released reports on the opinions of gun owners and non-gun owners.  Here are where gun owners and non-owners disagree based on recent polling data.

The urban/rural divide-

Gun-culture 2.0 is centered around self-defense rather than hunting.  That motivation has grown in recent years but there is still a large urban/rural divide in gun ownership and the attitude towards firearms.  Most rural households have a gun.  Urban households with a gun remain a minority. You’re almost twice as likely to live with a gun in your home if you live in the country as opposed to the city.  There are similarities.  A majority of gun owners in both settings have a loaded gun easily accessible.  

There are also large differences between the urban and rural culture.  A majority of rural non-gun owners say they have friends who own guns.   Despite the myth of urban diversity, a minority of urban non-gun owners say they have friends who own guns.   There is some common ground between gun owners and non-gun owners.  A majority of non-gun owners in both urban and rural areas say they have at least fired a gun.


The handgun owners who carry concealed are significantly more likely to be NRA members than those handgun owners who don’t carry.  NRA members are significantly less supportive of background checks than are non-NRA gun owners.  Gun owners who are NRA members were almost five times more likely to contact their political representatives about gun policy than gun owners who are not NRA members.

Sexual division-

People who admit over the phone to owning a gun are three times more likely to be male than female.  On average, women learned about guns when they were 8 years older than when men learned about guns.  Women are a growing part of the gun culture, but they have not reached parity yet.

Disagreement about safe storage-

Non-gun owners have different standards of gun safety than people who actually own a gun.  A majority of non-gun owners think all guns should be kept unloaded at all times with ammunition stored separately.  A majority of gun owners disagree.  That divergent opinion might be explained by the reality of keeping both guns and ammunition in a locked gun safe.  We simply don’t know.

Duty to inform-

A minority of both gun owners and non-gun owners say it is essential to tell visitors there is a gun in the home.  Though a minority view, non-gun owners were almost five times as likely to say that gun owners should tell visitors that there is a gun in the home. Non-gun owners were almost twice as likely to say there is a duty to inform if the visitors have children.  Again, this difference may be masked by the practice of safe storage.

Personal protection versus sporting use-

The majority of gun owners say they own a gun for personal protection.  A majority of gun owners also say that they feel safer having a gun in their home.  As expected, a minority of people living without a gun in the home feel that having a gun would make them feel safer.

Safety training-

A clear majority of gun owners say they have taken a firearms safety course.  A majority of non-gun owners say that safety training is essential but they have never taken such training themselves.  I wonder who will teach their children about gun safety?

The right to keep and bear-

Gun owners and non-gun owners disagree on the right to keep and bear arms.  They disagree about banning “assault weapons”, banning “high capacity magazines”, and reducing the number and type of “gun-free” zones.  Non-gun owners think gun laws work.

Guns and crime-

Gun owners think legal gun ownership reduces crime, while non-gun owners think legal gun ownership leads to more crime.  Non-gun owners think easier access to legal gun ownership would lead to mass shootings.  They think legal gun owners are part of the problem.  Gun owners disagree.

The poll gives us public opinion.  We may argue that the opinion is uninformed or inaccurate, but that is a separate discussion.  It shows us the clear differences between the gun culture and opinions held by the majority.

The second part of this series is here.
I gave you 600 words.  Please leave a comment, a like, and a share. RM

20 Comments leave one →
  1. KUETSA permalink
    July 17, 2017 8:43 pm

    Whatever opinion anyone may or may not have is irrelevant.

    SHALL NOT BE INFRINGED is translated to the reality:

    Shall not be limited or restricted so as to reduce CAPABILITY!

    The Second Amendment is a Constitutionally protected right to the CAPABILITY of American Citizens to ENFORCE the keeping of their freedoms.

    There is NO room for surrender in any of this discussion.

    We are at a stand-off through NON-COMPLIANCE at this point – in several progressive states.

    Progressives would be fools to to force our need to ENFORCE the keeping of our freedom!


  2. July 18, 2017 6:24 am

    Yes, to limit comments like this.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. MaddMedic permalink
    July 18, 2017 7:56 am

    Reblogged this on Freedom Is Just Another Word….


  4. revjen45 permalink
    July 18, 2017 8:26 am

    2A ensures the ability of Free Americans to act individually and in concert for the preservation of social order and Constitutional principles when .gov fails to do so. Shall not be infringed means not to be reduced by one iota. Not too hard to understand when viewed through the lens of truth.
    The People ARE the Militia.


  5. Doug permalink
    July 18, 2017 8:26 am

    What PEW doesn’t, and probably cannot account for is people telling them the truth. If someone called me on the phone asking about guns, my response would be none of your business.


  6. Uncle Lar permalink
    July 18, 2017 9:28 am

    I suspect that the survey is highly skewed towards non gun owners.
    Very few of my gun owning friends would be comfortable even admitting to gun ownership to an anonymous caller on the phone.


  7. July 18, 2017 12:21 pm

    It’s all in the wording of the questions. I can get the majority of people to agree to ban water from society if I get to be the one asking the questions. And asking a general question such as “Should gun buyers get a background check at a gun show” will give you that “90%” agreement that the gun-banners are always bragging about.


  8. Barry Hirsh permalink
    July 18, 2017 12:56 pm

    “The poll gives us public opinion. We may argue that the opinion is uninformed or inaccurate, but that is a separate discussion.”

    Yes, it may be both of those, but here’s what it actually is – irrelevant. Keeping and bearing arms is a fundamental individual right that needs no justification for its existence, it is a right enshrined in and protected by our Constitution with the scope understood by the public at the time of ratification, and as such, it is immune from the vicissitudes of public opinion.


    • July 18, 2017 7:03 pm

      The very purpose of the Bill of Rights was to withdraw certain subjects from the vicissitudes of political controversy, to place them beyond the reach of majorities and officials and to establish them as legal principles to be applied by the Courts. One’s right to life, liberty, and property, to free speech, a free press, freedom of worship and assembly, and other fundamental rights, may not be submitted to vote; they depend on the outcome of no elections.”
      319 US 624 AT 638

      A citizen’s constitutional rights can hardly be infringed simply because a majority of the people choose that it be.



  1. The Divergent Opinions Between Gun Owners and Non-Gun Owners
  2. Where We Disagree : The Divergent Opinions Between Gun Owners & Non-Gun Owners – Minnesota Gun Rights
  3. Stop Bigotry Against Armed America | SlowFacts
  4. Stop the Bigotry Against Armed America.
  5. Stop Bigotry Against Law Abiding, Armed America | The Daily Headline News
  6. Stop Bigotry Against Law Abiding, Armed America – Minnesota Gun Rights
  7. What Does the American Majority Think? - Blame Gun Owners ~ VIDEO
  8. What Does the American Majority Think? – Blame Gun Owners ~ VIDEO | The Daily Headline News
  9. What Does the American Majority Think? – Blame Gun Owners ~ VIDEO – Minnesota Gun Rights
  10. What Does the American Majority Think? – Blame Gun Owners ~ VIDEO - 2nd Amendment Right
  11. Time For Gun Owners To Demand A Stop To Bigotry Against Armed America

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: